Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles in Michigan: What to Consider

The choice of a metal roof vs asphalt shingles comes down to more than appearance. Both can be appropriate for Michigan homes, but the right choice depends on your budget, roof design, the product you select and how long you plan to stay in your home.

Upfront cost and long-term plans

Asphalt shingles often have a lower initial cost than a professionally installed metal roof. Metal roofing typically costs more upfront, but some products can offer a longer service life. Actual costs vary with roof size, pitch, access, tear-off, materials and the details around chimneys and valleys. Ask for proposals based on the same scope so you can compare them fairly.

Performance in Michigan weather

Both systems need proper underlayment, flashing, ventilation and installation. Product ratings and installation requirements vary, so ask about the specific shingle or metal system being proposed. Metal can shed snow, but snow may slide suddenly from certain roof designs. Discuss snow guards and areas above entrances or walkways with your contractor.

Style, sound and maintenance

Shingles come in many colors and profiles, while metal offers styles ranging from standing seam panels to products made to resemble other materials. Sound during rain depends on the complete roof assembly, including decking and insulation. Both types should be checked periodically for damaged components, debris and problem flashing.

Understand the warranty and the details

Ask who covers materials and workmanship, what is excluded, and whether registration or maintenance is required. A metal roof quote should identify the panel type and finish; a shingle quote should specify the product and roofing components. Review how the contractor will handle ventilation and any damaged decking.

How roof design affects your choice

Roof pitch, valleys, dormers, chimneys and areas where the roof meets a wall all affect the installation. Some products have minimum slope requirements and specific details for flashing and fastening. Your contractor should consider the whole roof and the manufacturer’s instructions before recommending a particular system.

If a home has complex rooflines, comparing complete project proposals is especially useful. Ask whether each estimate includes tear-off, underlayment, ventilation, flashing and the same treatment of damaged decking. A material price alone does not represent the finished project.

Metal roof vs asphalt shingles: questions about durability

Neither material is maintenance-free or immune to damage. Wind, debris, hail, installation quality and the surrounding environment can affect performance. Asphalt shingle wind ratings depend on the specific product and installation method. Metal panel finishes, fasteners and details also vary. Ask to see the product information and discuss what is suitable for your home.

If one area is damaged years later, availability and appearance of replacement materials may matter. Matching faded shingles can be difficult, and metal repairs depend on the panel system and location. Ask what a future repair could involve instead of assuming one product will always be easier to fix.

How do the warranties compare?

Warranty terms are specific to the manufacturer, product, installation and registration requirements. Ask for the written material warranty and separate workmanship terms. Review limitations, transfer rules, exclusions and the process for reporting a concern. A long advertised warranty is not the same as a guarantee that every type of damage will be covered.

Questions to bring to your estimate

  • Which exact products and colors are included?
  • What is the complete installed cost, including tear-off and cleanup?
  • How will ventilation, flashing and damaged decking be handled?
  • Are snow retention devices recommended above walkways?
  • What are the material and workmanship warranty terms?

Explore our standing seam and exposed fastener metal roofing options alongside our roof replacement services. Review the factors that affect roof replacement cost when comparing complete proposals. For product-specific asphalt shingle information, see CertainTeed’s residential roofing resources.

Top Gun Roofing & Exteriors works with homeowners throughout West Michigan. Contact us for an estimate and a conversation about the options that fit your home.

Metal Roofing and Asphalt Shingle FAQs

Is a metal roof more expensive than asphalt shingles?

Metal roofing typically costs more upfront, but prices depend on the specific products, roof design and installation. Request estimates with comparable scopes to understand the difference for your home.

Does snow slide off a metal roof?

Snow can slide from metal roofing, depending on the roof and weather conditions. Ask your contractor whether snow retention is appropriate above entrances, walkways or other areas.

Will a metal roof be noisy when it rains?

Sound depends on the complete roof assembly, including decking, insulation and the installation. Ask how the proposed system will be installed on your home.

Request a Free Roofing Estimate

Ready to compare options for your home? Call (616) 900-8033 or fill out our contact form to request a free estimate. Top Gun serves Wyoming, Grand Rapids and communities throughout West Michigan.

Read our customer reviews.

Scroll to Top